# Math Puzzle Monday!

Time for another puzzle! This week, we have a hexagon puzzle, which serves as a good workout both for place value and for problem-solving skills:

Click on the picture for a pdf of the puzzle.

And here’s the solution:

# Math Puzzle Monday!

My apologies for not posting for so long… we’ve recently moved to a new apartment and that has been taking up all of my energy. Starting today, I’m going to try to actually post a puzzle each week, as well as continue explaining my educational philosophy in other posts.

This week’s puzzle is a math crossword! This one requires understanding of addition, subtraction, and multiplication. Click on the picture to load a printable pdf:

And here’s the solution:

# Math Puzzle Monday!

Time for another puzzle! This week, we have another shape puzzle. We do shape puzzles every day, and I’ve been very pleased with their effect on a child’s mental model of variables.

Click on the picture to get a printable pdf:

And here’s the solution:

# Math Puzzle Monday!

Another Monday, another puzzle! This week, we have a magic square, but a trickier one. In this puzzle, you aren’t immediately given a complete row or column, so you can’t simply solve for the common sum and then solve for all the other entries. There’s a trick to these… can you figure it out?

Click on the image to get a copy of the pdf:

And here’s the solution:

# Math Puzzle Monday!

Sorry I’ve missed the last two weeks﹣we’ve been a bit too busy around here! I’ll try to keep up with the puzzles (and other posts) moving forward.

This week’s puzzle is a crossword. This one uses multiplication as well as addition and subtraction:

Click on the puzzle to open a pdf file.

And here’s the solution:

# Math Puzzle Monday!

Time for our weekly puzzle! This week, we have another knight’s tour puzzle. This one is hard to do without a good understanding of place value!

Click on the image for a pdf copy of the puzzle.

And here’s the solution:

# The Basics

The more I post on this site, the clearer it becomes to me that what I need is a “basics” series: a series in which I explain how I introduce the fundamental building blocks of elementary mathematics. Only in the context of these definitions will the work I do with my kids make sense.

What I focus on with my kids are the fundamental mental models that underpin much of elementary mathematics. These include place value, the four elementary arithmetic operations, and the concept of equality. I primarily focus on these concepts and the interactions between them, largely forgoing “extras” like telling time, using money, naming unusual shapes, and many other things that often gets stuffed into modern curricula. In my opinion, these topics are best encountered informally “in the wild.” As a child becomes more proficient with the basic models of arithmetic, they will be able to apply arithmetic to a wider range of questions. However, in my opinion, including these topics in the curriculum wastes valuable time best spend on the fundamentals.

Another early concept I spend a lot of time on is the concept of a variable. Algebra is a generalization of arithmetic: it is arithmetic done with an arbitrary number instead of a specific number. The right time to start generalizing one’s observations about numbers is when one is working with numbers in a hands-on way. And similarly, the right time to build a robust mental model of a variable is when one is doing arithmetic.

When taken together, these basics form a large part of our elementary mathematics program. I hope this series helps explain how we approach our journey!

This is the introduction to a series of posts about our basic approach. Here’s are my first and second posts about place value. Here’s a post about arithmetic operations. I will soon also add posts about equality, variables, and a couple of detailed examples of our daily lessons.

# Math Puzzle Monday!

Time for another puzzle! This one is an equation grid and it’s relatively straightforward for a child who has a good understanding of place value, the arithmetic operations, and equality. Note that a child does NOT need to be able to actually subtract 27 from 25 to be able to check whether 2 = 25﹣27. They merely need to be able to think about what happens if you try to take away 27 from 25.

Here’ the puzzle:

Click on the image to get a copy of a pdf of the puzzle.

And here’s a solution to the puzzle:

# The Operations

In this post, I’m going to give a brief description of how I introduce each arithmetic operation. Due to my focus on mental models, I give a specific definition for each operation and then give the children a lot of time to explore them. This exploration is done in the context of place value.

I introduce the operations in the following order: addition, subtraction, multiplication, division. I introduce each new operation as soon as the definition and symbol of the previous operation have been internalized. I do not wait for math facts to be memorized or for secondary meanings to be learned. The following are my definitions:

Addition: I’ve talked about this operation briefly in my series about counting on. I introduce addition as “putting together.” In my experience, most children have some experience with this operation from daily life and can think about questions such as “What do we get if put 2 cookies and another 2 cookies together?”

Subtraction: I introduce subtraction purely “taking away.” This means that I do not treat it as obvious that subtraction also tells us how much bigger one number is than another. An expression like 5﹣3 means no more and no less than “what we get if we take 3 away from 5.”

The benefit of this definition is that this provides a robust mental model that makes it clear that subtraction is not commutative: that is, that 3﹣5 is not the same thing as 5﹣3. I’ve met many children without a clear mental model who do not distinguish between the two.

Multiplication: I introduce multiplication as “taking copies.” Specifically, I say that the first number tells us how many copies to take, and the second number tells us what number we’re taking copies of. For example, 3⨉5 is defined as 3 copies of 5 and 5⨉6 is defined as 5 copies of 6.

I do not treat it as given that multiplication is commutative from the beginning. Therefore, for my students 3⨉5 means 3 copies of 5 and does not mean 5 copies of 3, which would be written as 5⨉3.

Division: I introduce division as “splitting into a certain number of groups,” where the first number tells us how many things we are splitting, and the second number tells us how many groups we are splitting into. For example, 12 ÷ 3 is defined as the answer to “What do we get if we split 12 things between 3 people?”

As usual, I do not assume other meanings of the symbol from the beginning. For example, I do not treat it as given that 12 ÷ 3 also tells us the number of groups of 3 that we could split 12 into. In my experience, the fact that the answer to those two questions is the same is not at all obvious to most kids.

Some of these definitions require minor tweaking as we move into fractions, but overall, these mental models stay constant for my students throughout elementary math. This allows them to gain comfort with using them and results in excellent intuition about the operations and the relationships between them.

As I walk you through our lessons, you will see that we eventually learn all the standard properties of the operations that kids are often taught to take for granted. However, this does not happens early on as part of the definition! It happens organically as they gain fluency and as their mental models get more robust.

This is a post in a series about our basic approach. Here’s the introduction to the series. Here’s are my first and second posts about place value. I will soon also add posts about equality and variables, as well as a couple of detailed examples of our daily lessons.

# Lesson Plan: Introducing Place Value

Required Skills: the ability to fluently count on, preferably the ability to read numbers up to 100 by rote (although this can be taught concurrently.)

Required Objects: any counters that can be used to distinguish between ones, tens, and eventually hundreds. Inspired by this excellent post, I use differently-colored poker chips, but you could also use labeled place value disks, or cardboard squares, or whatever appeals to you and is easy for your child to manipulate and remember. However, it’s best for these to neither be groupings of objects nor to be proportional to the quantities they represent.

In my last post, I discussed the fact that while the mental model for place value is simple and easily absorbed with exposure, most kids struggle to use the model fluently. This is an immediate outcome of the fact that we spend far more time teaching the consequences of the model than we do teaching the model itself.

So how can we teach place value effectively? The important thing is to present children with the abstract model in a shape that allows them to calculate effectively. The key feature of place value is the fact that the different digits in a number represent copies of different quantities, and that the quantity represented by a specific digit is ten times greater than the quantity represented by the digit to its right, with the rightmost digit representing ones. This is, in fact, the entirety of the place value model. At its heart, place value is a trading model and it should be presented as such. The consequences can wait.

Here’s how I introduce place value. I first introduce the child to the manipulatives we will be using. In my classes, ones are represented by blue poker chips and tens are represented by green poker chips. I explain that the green poker chips are worth ten times as much as the blue ones: that is, a green poker chip can be traded for ten blue poker chips. (Place value requires facility with the idea of a number as a unit, which is why I prefer to teach place value after counting on is mastered﹣counting on requires this facility as well.) We practice that for a bit, and then I explain how these new tools are related to the way we write numbers. I write an example of a two-digit number: for example, we may use a 53. I tell the child that the rightmost digit tells us how many blues to take, while the digit left of it tells us how many greens (in other words, tens) to take. And I have the child actually demonstrate this with the chips:

We then practice representing a few more two-digit numbers in poker chips. And that’s it for the introduction!

“Wait a minute. That’s IT?” you say. “This sounds exactly like what everyone else does, except for the fact that you’re using poker chips. And you said the poker chips aren’t essential, anyway. How’s this different from what other people do?”

Actually, you’re right. The above introduction is very similar to what most conceptual programs do to introduce place value. The difference is not in the introduction but in what I do next. Remember, my goal is to get kids to internalize mental models, and my expectation is that mental models take a long time to get integrated. To absorb the place value model, kids have to use it over and over and over again, until trading the quantities represented by the digits becomes second nature. When we introduce the poker chips, we introduce a way for children to use a highly abstract trading model in a hands-on way. The poker chips are not the destination but a tool. They allow children to actively engage with an abstraction.

Once I introduce the poker chips, they become our main model of number. We use them for all calculations and all operations. And in the process of using them, the mental model slowly and surely gets developed.

This is a post in a series about our basic approach. Here’s the introduction to the series. Here’s my first post about place value. Here’s a post about arithmetic operations. I will soon also add posts about equality and variables, as well as a couple of detailed examples of our daily lessons.